Fucking rad, I think. Immediately I set out on my path to becoming an expert baker and sticking it to the commercial bakeries that have kept me under their thumb for decades. Those sick bastards, they took the universal symbol of sustenance right out of our proletariat hands and sold it back to us as indecipherable magic.
Le First Attempt
Initial Reaction: I AM A GOD! LOOK AT THIS BEAUTIFUL FUCKING THING. FIRST TIME OUT OF THE GATE, HOME RUN SUCKERS. EAT A DICK BAKERS OF THE WORLD, COLLIN HAS YOUR NUMBER DUDES.
After Eating and Contemplation: Well, this isn't very good. It sure as shit looked fabulous, but the crumb was dense, overly chewy and the flavor profile was as flat as the Midwestern states. Besides the salt, there's nothing that the palate attaches to. Also the crust is thick, tough and while browned nicely it has no crackling quality.
I made this first loaf nearly a year ago. The rabbit hole has no bottom. That's the thing with bread, it's not easy and it's not quick. The notion that you can make it in a few hours and have something to be proud of is total and complete bullshit.
Subsequent Shots In The Dark
This was the last loaf of bread I made using only commercial yeast. It came out OK, I let it proof longer than the first attempt and I baked it in a cast iron dutch oven. Note the crackling blisters on the crust, looks pretty on point yeah? It was, but it still wasn't there, the crumb was still too dense, the flavor still lacked any bite. It became clear to me that I was actually looking for a sourdough bread, and not this pansy shit.
Getting a sourdough starter going took a few weeks. The first batch was overrun by some incredibly active bacteria that caused it to quadruple in size and burst out of it's mason jar container. I tried to salvage it using the regular, dump all but 100g, feed, wait, method. But it was a loss, so I fired it up again. Eventually I got something like a stable colony, I could add flour and water and get a doubling in size quickly. The whole thing had a pungent smell to it that bit the nostrils and if left for too long without attending it would produce a nice layer of alcoholic liquid atop it, but the yeast would spring right back upon feeding.
Time heals all wounds and makes better bread. This was the first loaf I ever made with my sourdough starter and handled this dough with kid gloves from start to finish. I made the starter for this 2 days in advance, let it rise in the fridge for nearly 24 hours, made the dough, let it proof in the fridge for 24 hours, then shaped it that morning, let it sit out for 5 or so hours, reshaped, and baked. That's like 3 days of thinking about bread to make two loaves of edible sourdough. Edible, not great. That's a far-fucking-cry from a few hours.
The Best Yet
I'll level with you, I don't remember what the hell I did special to make this bread, other than give it plenty of retarded proofing time in the fridge. It was easily the best sourdough I've made to-date. It had all the rustic appeal of a log cabin and if someone with any photographic ability had shot the thing it could have graced the cover of cookbook. It tasted good to boot! Though my starter still didn't have that bite associated with San Francisco sourdough, but it had nuance and depth that none of the other loaves had yet managed.
That brings us to present day. I've made loaves since the God-loaf, but I never took as much time and care in doing so, and the results have suffered greatly.
Really, after a year of bread making I've only learned one important thing. Give it time. Yeast is the single best thing in the world, it gives us both booze and bread, so pay it the respect it deserves and let it work. Don't trust anyone who says you can make great bread in an afternoon, the proofing time is what gives a depth of flavor and gasses out the dough to have that wonderful look and texture. Also, once you've gotten dough proofed and smelling/feeling sexy, don't fuck with it too much. Be gentle when shaping so you don't loose all that you've waited so long to obtain.
Bread is such a simple thing on the surface, but that simplicity is only perceived. Once you go beyond putting water, flour, salt and yeast together in the right ratio you're immediatley in a more complex space. But it's a fun space, if not a bit maddening







